Permaculture Soils Logo

permaculturesoils.com

Menu

Historical Comparison

Comparing 2012 (Steve Solomon) vs 2025 (Eurofins APAL) soil tests for Abdallah locations. A 13-year perspective on soil evolution.

Catastrophic Accumulation

Zinc increased by 310-380% and copper by 430-850% over 13 years. These are now at toxic levels requiring immediate remediation.

Abdallah Back
Nutrient changes (2012-2025)
Nutrient20122025Change
Zinc124.0254.0
+104.8%
Copper3.28.7
+171.2%
Sulfur22.022.0
0%
Calcium1457.04820.0
+230.8%
Abdallah Front
Nutrient changes (2012-2025)
Nutrient20122025Change
Zinc117.0220.0
+88%
Copper2.09.5
+373%
Sulfur18.018.3
+1.7%
Calcium3110.04650.0
+49.5%
What Happened?

2012 Situation

Both locations had zinc deficiencies (117-124 mg/kg) and very low copper (2.0-3.2 mg/kg). Steve Solomon recommended copper sulfate and manganese sulfate.

The Mistake

Copper sulfate and zinc sulfate were likely applied repeatedly over multiple years without retesting. This ignored the "one-time application" warning.

2025 Result

Zinc: 220-254 mg/kg (5x target) • Copper: 8.7-9.5 mg/kg (toxic) • Sulfur: Still critically deficient.

Key Lessons
1

Test Annually

When adding concentrated minerals, you are flying blind without yearly tests.

2

Respect Limits

Max 7 lb/acre copper and 14 lb/acre zinc per year. Never exceed this.

3

Metals Accumulate

Unlike nitrogen, heavy metals stay in the soil for decades. They do not wash away easily.

4

Complete Prescriptions

The gypsum for sulfur was apparently missed, leading to continued deficiency.

Original 2012 Recommendations
From Steve Solomon's analysis service

Abdallah Back (2012)

  • Gypsum: 800g per 10m²
  • Manganese sulfate: 175g per 10m²
  • Copper sulfate: 30g per 10m²

Abdallah Front (2012)

  • Lime: 1000g per 10m²
  • Gypsum: 600g per 10m²
  • Copper sulfate: 30g per 10m²

These recommendations were for one-time application with retesting the following year. They were NOT meant to be repeated annually without testing.